News
Harvard Medical School Cancels Student Groups’ Pro-Palestine Vigil
News
Former FTC Chair Lina Khan Urges Democrats to Rethink Federal Agency Function at IOP Forum
News
Cyanobacteria Advisory Expected To Lift Before Head of the Charles Regatta
News
After QuOffice’s Closure, Its Staff Are No Longer Confidential Resources for Students Reporting Sexual Misconduct
News
Harvard Still On Track To Reach Fossil Fuel-Neutral Status by 2026, Sustainability Report Finds
John K. Fairbank '29, Francis Lee Higginson Professor of History, and Benjamin I. Schwartz, professor of History and Government, attacked President Nixon's reasons for continuing the war in Indochina at an informal gathering in the Kirkland House JCR last night.
Without specifically refuting Nixon's most recent speeches on the war, the two noted East Asian scholars criticized his "rationalizing rhetoric."
Fairbank, standing before his audience of more than 60 people, explained in his introductory statement that the ideals of repelling aggression, guaranteeing self-determination, and fighting communism or totalitarianism were part of an inherited American policy of "oyer-blown rhetoric" and that "these three ideals don't fit reality" in the present situation in Vietnam.
Appeasement
Schwartz added that U.S. policy was based too heavily on a desire to avoid another fatal policy of Munich-style appeasement. In order to withdraw from Vietnam. Schwartz noted, "we will be humiliated."
Blame
Schwartz also put some of the blame for American involvement in Vietnam on what he called "a new kind of moral arrogance." He described this attitude as the American mentality of "technocratic infallibility." the belief that we had mastered the "science of knowing how to handle it."
Fairbank, in the question-and-answer period, appeared to agree with the thrust of this new argument. He derided "the general models that usually involve the whole world" and put in a "plug" for the study of limited geographical areas.
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.