News
Adams Alumni Go Nuts for Newly Renovated House
News
A Better Cambridge Announces Endorsements in City Council Race, Giving Boost to Incumbents
News
HUA Kicks Off With Inaugural Meeting Under New Administration
News
Harvard Ends Undergraduate Minority Recruitment Program as Trump Targets Race in Admissions
News
Memorial Church Reduces Programming Amid University Budget Cuts
Debate of January 9, 1896.Question: Resolved, That the present powers of the Speaker of the House of Representatives are a menace to good government."
Brief for the Affirmative.A. M. KALES and G. L. PAINE.
Best general references: Bryce, American Commonwealth, I, 134-138; Smith, Const. Manual and Digest (see "Speaker" in Index) 52 Cong. 1 Sess. 1892; Lalor, Cyclopaedia, III. 91; A. B. Hart, Practical Essays, No. 1, pp. 1-19; J. G. Carlisle in North American Review, Vol. 150, pp. 390-400 (Mch. 1890); Senator Hoar in North American Review, Vol. 128, pp. 113-134 (Feb. 1879).
I. The Speakership should be a judicial position, entailing-(a) Familiarity with the rules.- (b) Strict impartiality: Bryce I. 134, 135; Nation, L, 143.
II. The present powers of the Speaker, as fixed by rule, are excessive.- (a) He practically makes the rules: Practical Essays. 15-17; 19th Century, XXVIII. 870.- (1) Appoints committee on rules.- (2) Is himself chairman of the committee.- (b) He interprets and applies the rules without appeal: Cong. Rec. 53 Cong. 2 Sess. 4667.- (c) He has unqualified veto power over every legislative action and also power to forward any measures: N. A. R. Vol. 150, 399; Nat. XXVI. 226; Practical Essays, p. 14; Cong. Rec. Vol. II. 43 Cong. 1st Sess. Appendix p. 25.- (1) He appoints the standing committees of the House to one of which he refers every bill without debate.- (2) He appoints the chairmen of
(Continued on fourth page.)
Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.