News

Penny Pritzker Says She Has ‘Absolutely No Idea’ How Trump Talks Will Conclude

News

Harvard Researchers Find Executive Function Tests May Be Culturally Biased

News

Researchers Release Report on People Enslaved by Harvard-Affiliated Vassall Family

News

Zusy Seeks First Full Term for Cambridge City Council

News

NYT Journalist Maggie Haberman Weighs In on Trump’s White House, Democratic Strategy at Harvard Talk

English VI.

Debate of May 16, 1895.

NO WRITER ATTRIBUTED

DEBATE OF NOVEMBER 16, 1887.Question: "Should the members of the President's Cabinet have seats and voices in Congress?"

Brief for the Affirmative.Best single reference: G. Bradford, address on "The Practical Working of our Government.

C. DeV. Musaus and F. L. Dean.I. The present system is adequate.- Overland Monthly, III., 17 et seq.; Lockwood, Abolition of the Presidency, 114-116.

II. The proposal is constitutional, and may be brought about by resolution.- Story's Commentaries, S 869, et seq., J. C. Hamilton's Life of Hamton, IV., 67; Benton's Abridgement, I., 109.

III. It will make possible a continuous policy.

IV. Statesmanlike debate will be promoted.

General refererences: U. S. Senate Reports, 46th Cong., 3d Sess., No. 837: Lockwood's Abolition of the Presidency, chap. X.; Contemporary Review, Dec. 1885, p. 864; National Review, Nov., 1864, p. 1; Atlantic Monthly, April, 1886, p. 542; International Review, VII., 147.

Brief for the Negative.Best Single Reference: Morrill's speech, found in the Congressional Record of the 46th Cong. sess., pp. 971-974.

William Barnes, Jr. and E. C. Mason.

I. The principal of the U. S. Government would be undermined by the proposed change.- Von Holst's Constitutional Law, SS 25 and 26; Morrill's speech, 46th Cong., 1st session, Cong. Record, p. 9 72.

(a) Violation of the separation between the executive and legislative branches.

(b) Violation of the spirit of the Constitution in other respects.

II. The change to be effective implies, in time, a responsible ministry.- Bagehot's Eng. Const., chap. on the cabinet; Nation, xvi.., 234.

III. A responsible ministry would combletely subvert our present form of Government.- Nation, xxviii., 243.

IV. There serious practical objections to the working of the plan.- Morrills' speech, Congressional Record, 1st session 46th Congress p. 974.

V. The change is advocated on an imperfect apprehension of the history of the English Constitution.

Want to keep up with breaking news? Subscribe to our email newsletter.

Tags